Kero.

Covering a protest without a press card

Freelancer, journalism student, independent videographer or crew member: what France’s national policing doctrine provides to identify you, what it lets you do during a demonstration, and its limits.

Updated on

A press card is not mandatory

France’s national policing doctrine for demonstrations (Schéma national du maintien de l’ordre, SNMO), in its December 2021 version, states that the presence of journalists at demonstrations is “of paramount importance” and that it is “imperative to protect the right to inform”. It only asks that journalists be able to establish their status with the police “clearly”.

A press card is one way to do so, not the only one: the text says showing it “is sufficient”, but that “there are other means of identification”. The attestation template annexed to the doctrine also states that “no form of accreditation may be required of journalists and those accompanying them to cover a demonstration on the public highway”.

Sources: Légifrance — full text of the doctrine and its annexes (official PDF)

What the doctrine is — and is not

The SNMO is a doctrine document of the French Interior Ministry, which describes it as its “first doctrine document on the subject common to all forces”. The current version was sent to prefects, the police and the gendarmerie by a circular dated 15 December 2021. It is not a law: the circular that issues it presents it as “the new reference for policing demonstrations”.

The Conseil d’État drew a limit in 2021: as head of department, the Interior Minister has no power to set conditions on journalists wearing protective equipment, “nor indeed for anyone taking part in or attending a demonstration”.

In practice, the doctrine does not guarantee that nothing will happen on the ground. It gives you reference points to rely on and a document to cite if problems arise.

Sources: Légifrance — circular of 15 December 2021, National policing doctrine (SNMO), December 2021 version · Légifrance — full text of the doctrine and its annexes (official PDF) · Conseil d’État — decision no. 444849 of 10 June 2021

The two ways to prove you are a journalist

Under § 2.2.1 of the doctrine, journalists can prove their status in two ways:

  • by showing, if they hold one, their professional journalist identity card (the French “press card”) or the international press card issued by the International Federation of Journalists (IFJ);
  • by showing a standard identification attestation, supplied by their employer or commissioning client (print publisher, broadcaster or audiovisual company, news agency) or by their journalism school. The doctrine says this attestation, usable from 1 January 2022, “has been validated by the profession and recognised by the Interior Ministry”.

The attestation also covers people accompanying a journalist (technician, security agent, etc.).

For the “rare cases” where neither option is possible, the doctrine announced an ad hoc document, to be drawn up with the profession and the Culture and Interior ministries, “by 1 July 2022”. We could not verify on an official source whether that document has been published.

Sources: Légifrance — full text of the doctrine and its annexes (official PDF)

The attestation: formal requirements

The template is in Annex I of the doctrine. It must be drawn up on the issuing organisation’s letterhead and includes:

  • the name and position of the signatory within the organisation;
  • the type of organisation: press publisher (print or online), audiovisual company (broadcaster or producer), news agency or journalism school;
  • the name of the journalist (or companion) and a statement that they report on, or accompany journalists at, demonstrations on the public highway for the organisation;
  • a validity period “from [date] to [date]”, which must be no longer than one quarter;
  • the place, date, signature and a block of legal information about the organisation.

The attestation itself lists the four guarantees it allows you to rely on (see below) and the sentence stating that no accreditation may be required. Remember to have it renewed before the period ends.

Sources: Légifrance — full text of the doctrine and its annexes (official PDF)

The four guarantees for journalists

§ 2.2.3 sets out four provisions specific to journalists. Applying them “nevertheless requires that they can prove their status by presenting one of the documents mentioned”: press card, IFJ card or attestation.

  1. A liaison channel with a designated officer (§ 2.2.3.1): for all major public demonstrations, a police liaison officer on the ground runs a dedicated channel with the media throughout the event. It is used to share operational information, resolve problems and report violence against journalists. Access is on request and is “automatically” granted.
  2. Freedom of movement within police lines (§ 2.2.3.2): unlike other people present, journalists may move freely within security cordons.
  3. Staying during a dispersal (§ 2.2.3.3): journalists may keep working when a gathering is dispersed without having to leave, provided they position themselves so they cannot be mistaken for participants and do not obstruct the police. This applies to declared demonstrations as well as banned or undeclared ones.
  4. Protection (§ 2.2.3.4): journalists may, by way of exception, position themselves behind police cordons, and may wear protective equipment.

Sources: Légifrance — full text of the doctrine and its annexes (official PDF)

The “press” armband: useful, not mandatory

§ 2.2.2 of the doctrine states that journalists are not obliged to wear distinctive signs (“press” on an armband, vest, etc.), but that these can make it easier for the police to identify them “so as to take them better into account”. An armband does not replace the card or attestation, which are still needed to rely on the four guarantees.

Sources: Légifrance — full text of the doctrine and its annexes (official PDF)

Filming and photographing the police

§ 2.2.5 of the doctrine states that the police “cannot object to images or sound being recorded during operations in public places”, except for staff in units legally entitled to anonymity. It refers to the Interior Minister’s circular of 23 December 2008, annexed to the doctrine, under which it is out of the question to arrest someone for that reason alone, journalist or not, to take their equipment or to destroy the recording.

The same paragraph notes that “publishing files listing police officers or gendarmes is now an offence”. The doctrine’s PDF cites “art 266-16-2” of the Criminal Code: the actual article is 226-16-2, in force since 27 May 2021. It punishes with five years’ imprisonment and a €300,000 fine the processing of personal data about civil servants or people entrusted with a public service mission, because of that role, outside the purposes allowed by the GDPR and the French Data Protection Act.

Sources: Légifrance — full text of the doctrine and its annexes (official PDF) · Légifrance — article 226-16-2 of the Criminal Code

Mask, goggles, helmet: the limit set by article 431-9-1

Article 431-9-1 of the Criminal Code punishes with one year’s imprisonment and a €15,000 fine anyone who, within or in the immediate vicinity of a demonstration on the public highway during or after which public-order disturbances occur or are likely to occur, deliberately conceals all or part of their face “without legitimate reason”.

The text contains no express exception for the press: what matters is whether there is a legitimate reason. Before the Conseil d’État, the Interior Ministry itself argued that journalists present for work “in principle” have a legitimate reason to wear safety equipment, “notably masks, goggles and helmets”. The 2021 doctrine states that journalists “may wear protective equipment” (§ 2.2.3.4).

Sources: Légifrance — article 431-9-1 of the Criminal Code · Conseil d’État — decision no. 444849 of 10 June 2021 · Légifrance — full text of the doctrine and its annexes (official PDF)

What the Conseil d’État struck down in 2021

On an application by, among others, the national journalists’ union (SNJ) and the Human Rights League, the Conseil d’État annulled on 10 June 2021 (no. 444849) four provisions of the first version of the doctrine, dated 16 September 2020:

  • in § 2.2.1, the words making journalists’ protective equipment conditional on “their identification being confirmed and their conduct free of any offence or provocation”: the minister had no power to set such rules;
  • in § 2.2.2, the words “accredited with the authorities”, which reserved the dedicated information channel for accredited journalists: given the lack of detail on such accreditation, the court found a disproportionate infringement of press freedom and freedom of communication;
  • the whole of § 2.2.4, which stated that the offence of remaining in a gathering after a warning had “no exception, including for journalists” and ordered journalists to leave during a dispersal;
  • § 3.1.4, on the kettling of demonstrators, because it did not precisely define when the technique may be used.

The circular of 15 December 2021 states that the new version takes this decision into account, with a section on journalists “entirely reworked with representatives of the profession and the Ministry of Culture”.

Sources: Conseil d’État — decision no. 444849 of 10 June 2021 · Légifrance — circular of 15 December 2021, National policing doctrine (SNMO), December 2021 version · Légifrance — full text of the doctrine and its annexes (official PDF)

If something goes wrong on the ground

At a major demonstration, the liaison channel provided by the doctrine is also used to report violence against journalists “so that it is stopped”. Afterwards, you can refer the matter to the Defender of Rights free of charge; it covers the policing of demonstrations, among other things. For the national police, a report can also be made to the IGPN, and for the gendarmerie to the IGGN.

If you are asked to prove your identity, you can do so by any means; documents with a photo carry more weight.

Sources: Légifrance — full text of the doctrine and its annexes (official PDF) · service-public.gouv.fr — Disputes with law enforcement · service-public.gouv.fr — Identity checks

Official text: download the national policing doctrine (PDF, Légifrance, in French) .

General information, checked against the sources cited on the update date shown, based on the December 2021 version of the doctrine published on Légifrance. The doctrine is administrative guidance, not law, and may change. This guide is not a substitute for advice from a lawyer, your union or your newsroom.